This may not come as a surprise, but I do not read German-language newspapers on a regular basis. Dial of a vintage Omega Constellation, pie pan. I am, however, keenly interested in a scandal involving the Swatch Group and a "Frankenwatch" Speedmaster which was sold at auction a while back for over $3 million. I won't go into all the minute details here, but the punchline is that Swatch Group bought the watch only to discover that some of its own employees may have been part of a conspiracy to assemble a watch which would be quite rare and important if it were authentic. But, apparently, it was not authentic. When the deception was uncovered, various people who were part of the "inside job" lost employment and, reportedly, legal authorities were notified in Switzerland. I originally wrote about this in 2023, you can read my coverage here.
There's been excellent reporting on this matter from many sources (see, for example, this story from Bloomberg). Notable among them is a German-language newspaper: Neue Zürcher Zeitung (NZZ). One thing I've discovered is that it is very challenging to gather information about the Swiss watch industry if you are not "on the ground" in Switzerland. Fortunately, NZZ is interested in the "Speedmaster Affair" and, since they have reporters in Switzerland, they often publish more details than I could ever obtain. Out of curiousity, I checked to see if they had updated their reporting and, sure enough, they have. So what more can we learn (note: I relied on Google Translate to provide an English version of the original text)?
The NZZ article reports that the head of Swatch Group, Nicolas Hayek, is confounded by how authorities have handled his company's complaint. NZZ reports that the public prosecutor's office in Bernese Jura-Seeland has made very limited progress in following up on the scandal. I quote NZZ: "The regional public prosecutor's office, where Omega filed the complaint, tried three times in the past eighteen months to pass the case on to the public prosecutor's office for economic crimes." NZZ further reports that this is a very unusual path for a criminal complaint to take.
The public prosecutor in question made the following observation when asked for an explanation by NZZ: "The longer an investigation takes, the clearer its contours become". A vintage Omega watch. Now, I know little about criminal investigations beyond what I've learned from television programs and movies. But I thought it was always best to follow leads before the "trail goes cold." I thought the window to solve a murder was 48 hours long and, after that, cracking the case was much, much harder. And what about that old chestnut "justice delayed is justice denied"?
I digress. NZZ did provide some new information regarding the state of the case. Omega's investigation suggests that 300 watches and watch components were stolen from their warehouse and archives. A grand total of five parties supposedly perpetrated the scandal: three internal to Omega and two outsiders. The total damage to Swatch Group was estimated at $6.3 million. And, even though the case was, in some sense, floundering in the public prosecutor's office, some progress has been made. According to NZZ "release of documents, house searches and the evaluation of seized electronic items" as well as "initial interviews" have all taken place.
The real risk with this kind of delay is that there may be more victims while the wheels of justice slowly grind away. According to NZZ, the two external parties are still exchanging watches with others on the secondary market. And, Swatch Group shareholders worldwide (including the Hayek family) do deserve some financial restitution, if at all possible. One thing is for certain, much of the Speedmaster Affair story is still untold.
My book on the history of Rolex marketing is now available on Amazon! It debuted as the #1 New Release in its category. You can find it here.
News recently broke that watch brand Rolex was on the receiving end of a €91 million fine levied by French authorities. A view of Rolex's offices in France. Source: Google Maps. Generally, the headlines ascribed this fine to Rolex's alleged practice of prohibiting online sales of its watches. However, I've looked closely at the situation and I don't think those headlines are completely accurate (although they're probably what French authorities would want you to believe). I came to this conclusion after reading a Google translation of a 134 page report issued by the French Competition Authority on December 19, 2023. Generally speaking, such documents do not make for engaging reading. However, for those who know how successful Rolex has been at maintaining a comparatively high level of corporate secrecy, the French report provides a compelling and rare insight into some specific aspects of the brand's business. It is these insights which lead me to conclu...
The other day, I was poking around in Swiss business registries (as one does on a weekend) when I noticed that Jörg Bucherer was still listed as the "president and delegate" of luxury watch retailer Bucherer, AG. A Rolex clock in front of an AD in New England. Since Bucherer, the man, passed away on November 8, 2023, this clearly raises some questions. More curious was the fact that Rolex ownership of Bucherer, the business, was not indicated in Bucherer's commercial registration and Rolex's own business registrations did not indicate a lash-up with Bucherer. News of Rolex's intent to acquire Bucherer broke roughly eight months ago. Now, I will admit that I do not understand or know all the nuances involved in Swiss business registration. I do know that registrations are administered by the Swiss cantons (roughly equivalent to states in the US) so perhaps this was simply a matter of delay in updating the registrations across cantons (Rolex is registered in G...
There's a quip in the world of finance: "nobody rings a bell at the top or bottom of the market." AI generated image of someone looking for the bottom of a chasm. If you're on a trading floor, you know it is the start of the day because of the "opening bell." But, if you reach the low point for prices, there is no bell. Everyone just has to do their best to figure out if prices are finally going to start increasing again. This is certainly true of watches. According to Chrono24's Chronopulse index of watch prices (full disclosure, I've contributed to this index), we've just begun the third year of a "bear market" for preowned watches. Chronopulse overall index of late. The rate of decrease in prices has certainly slowed, but there hasn't been an overall turnaround in prices just yet. It is hard to say if we're at the bottom or if we're just on a gentle downslope that will continue for the near term. Right or wron...
Comments
Post a Comment